Rex Heuermann plead not responsible Friday to 6 homicide counts in reference to the deaths of three of the “Gilgo 4,” as authorities reveal how mobile phone pings, selfies, a pizza field and his web searches led to arrest.
Rex Heuermann, 59, has formally been named and charged with the murders of three of the “Gilgo 4.”
On Friday, Heuermann plead not responsible throughout a courtroom look, after he was charged with six counts of homicide within the deaths of Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello. Although he has not but been charged with something associated to the fourth sufferer, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, his bail utility stated he was the “prime suspect” in her homicide because the investigation continues.
Talking with NBC, his protection lawyer Michael Brown stated, “I’ll say to you of us that it’s extraordinarily circumstantial in nature. When it comes to talking to my consumer, the one factor I can let you know that he did say, as he was in tears, was ‘I didn’t do that.'”
Getty / Suffolk County Police Division
Billy Baldwin Reveals Tie to Gilgo Seashore Homicide Suspect Rex Heuermann: ‘Thoughts-boggling’
View Story
The bail utility detailed how authorities first linked Heuermann to the murders of the 4 ladies, escorts whose our bodies had been found alongside Lengthy Island’s Ocean Parkway in 2010, after the disappearance of Shannan Gilbert, one other intercourse employee whose stays had been additionally discovered close by. Authorities beforehand stated they don’t imagine Gilbert was murdered, saying it was merely a “coincidence” she died in the identical space.
Investigators first zoned in on Heuermann after a brand new process pressure made up of the Suffolk County Police Division, New York State Police, Suffolk County Sheriff’s Workplace and Federal Bureau of Investigation was organized in 2022. It was then that they found the suspect owned a Chevy Avalanche on the time of the murders. A witness to Costello’s disappearance beforehand cited that very same make and mannequin because the one pushed by the killer.

Suffolk County Police Division
Suspect Arrested In Gilgo Seashore Serial Killer Case That is Stumped Police for Years
View Story
With that, “300 subpoenas, search warrants and different authorized processes to acquire proof” had been launched. In keeping with authorities, Heuermann’s mobile phone payments corresponded to places the place burner cellphones had been used to rearrange conferences with three of the 4 victims, in addition to “taunting” telephone calls to one of many sufferer’s family, a name made by a detective to Barthelemy’s telephone and a name checking voicemail on Brainard-Barnes’ telephone after her disappearance.
Authorities say they imagine Heuermann used two of the victims’ telephones after their deaths, each to examine voicemails and taunt Barthelemy’s household — making calls to Melissa’s sister from her personal cell wherein he “admitted killing and sexually assaulting” her.
Heuermann’s look, they famous within the docs, additionally “mirrors the bodily attributes” of certainly one of Costello’s purchasers, as described by a witness who stated he was a “massive, white male, roughly 6’4″ to six’6″ in peak, in his mid-forties, with ‘darkish bushy hair,’ and ‘huge oval type 1970’s sort eyeglasses.'” The witness additionally described him as an “ogre.”
Journey information additionally reportedly confirmed the suspect’s spouse was out of city when all three ladies disappeared.

County Court docket of Suffolk County
Investigators additionally say Heuermann was seen on surveillance video including extra minutes to a burner cellphone that was used for a variety of “prostitution-related contacts.” An e-mail account allegedly related to the identical telephone was used for “hundreds of searches associated to intercourse staff, sadistic, torture-related pornography and youngster pornography.” Lots of the queries associated to youngsters underneath the age of 13, in addition to searches for phrases together with “mistress lengthy island,” “tied up porn,” and “nude slave women.”
Greater than 200 searches linked to the identical e-mail account from March to June 2022 — simply after the Gilgo murders process pressure was introduced — associated to “lively and recognized serial killers,” the continued process pressure investigation itself and the names of the victims (above).
Amongst different search phrases: “why may legislation enforcement not hint the calls made by the lengthy island serial killer,” “In Lengthy Island serial killer investigation, new telephone know-how could also be key to interrupt in case,” “why hasn’t the lengthy island serial killer been caught” and “8 Terrifying Energetic Serial Killers (We Can’t Discover).”
An AOL account authorities say was additionally linked to the identical burner telephone included selfies “that appeared to have been taken by Defendant Rex Heuermann of himself” and had been “despatched to different individuals to solicit and prepare for sexual exercise.” These footage, supplied by investigators, are on the high of this text.
The burner telephone in query was additionally stated to be on Heuermann when he was arrested.

County Court docket of Suffolk County
After which comes the DNA proof.
In keeping with investigators, DNA left on crust situated inside a pizza field Heuermann threw away was collected and submitted for evaluation. Lab findings decided the mitochondrial DNA profile was “the identical” as hair discovered on a burlap bag used to “restrain and transport Megan Waterman’s bare and deceased physique.”
DNA obtained from bottles within the trash exterior Heuermann’s house was additionally analyzed, producing a profile for a feminine on the house. That profile matched that of an individual whose hair was additionally discovered in any respect three crime scenes. Investigators stated they imagine the pattern got here from Heuermann’s spouse — including that, since she was out of city on the time of the murders, some gadgets used throughout the killings got here from their house.
Heuermann is being held with out bail and can subsequent seem in courtroom on August 1.