An unrepentant maximalist whose style motion pictures are outlined by the mad gluttony of somebody born to go away all of it on display screen, Indonesian filmmaker Timo Tjahjanto is nothing if not simple to root for. There’s one thing indivisibly pure and valuable a few man who doesn’t know the which means of the phrases “too much;” whose horror stuff (particularly the “Safe Haven” brief he contributed to “V/H/S/2”) goes to date past the pale that it makes a scrumptious meal out of its personal unhealthy style, and whose orgiastic motion fare (“Headshot,” which Tjahjanto and Kimo Stamboel co-directed as The Mo Brothers) is so hyper-violent that it makes you surprise if it’s potential to expire of CGI blood.
Alas, that muchness — lovely because it is likely to be in principle — can be one thing of a double-edged sword, and Tjahjanto nonetheless isn’t exact sufficient to make use of it with out disfiguring his personal imaginative and prescient within the course of. Which is to say that, like “The Night Comes for Us” earlier than it, Tjahjanto’s newest and most bold symphony of stabbings is one other exhausting monument to its personal extra; a graceless orgy of loss of life and dismemberment that’s simpler to understand for its spirit than it’s to take pleasure in for its execution(s). Tedious, numbing, and all the time falling simply wanting the hard-boiled cool that it’s too spinoff to achieve for itself, “The Shadow Strays” is the work of a filmmaker whose enthusiasm continues to outstrip his talent. And whereas that giddy imbalance has all the time been the fundamental lifeblood of style cinema, the countless silhouette solid by Tjahjanto’s sprawling Netflix epic makes it simpler than ever to lose sight of the enjoyable we’re purported to be having with it.
“The Shadow Strays” begins as solely a film so dedicated to its “more is less” method ever might: With each a wall of expository textual content and a cryptic quote (credited to Medusa) that provides nothing to the motion that follows. The gist is that our merciless and unforgiving world has given rise to an ultra-secret clan of mercenaries who will kill anybody for the best value, no matter morals. They’re referred to as Shadows, they put on all black tactical gear which is a bit too chunky to look as cool because it ought to, and they’re going to fuck your shit all the best way up with out pondering twice.
Effectively, most of them will, anyway. It’s potential that the Shadow referred to as 13 (performed by a clean however believably harmful Angela Ribero) is likely to be a bit too soft-hearted for the lifetime of darkness that’s been assigned to her, as we see throughout the frenzied prologue wherein she’s tasked with eliminating a really cartoonish Yakuza clan deep inside the Sea of Bushes. It’s all enjoyable and video games for the primary couple of minutes; 13 decapitates heads so quick they whistle off their our bodies, drags a henchman’s balls immediately into the blade of a sword that’s protruding of the bottom, and makes certain to reacquaint us with Tjahjanto’s signature little bit of high-speed slaughter (repeatedly stabbing somebody within the chest at shut vary). However every thing adjustments on a dime when 13 by chance murders the geisha she was attempting to avoid wasting from being raped by the clan’s oyabun, a mistake that leaves our heroine so out of kinds that her soulless mentor (Hana Malasan as Umbra) has to select up the items. “Our mission is never easy but never complex,” Umbra tells her shaken pupil throughout her post-fight efficiency report, the cold-hearted killer successfully describing each motion film that Tjahjanto has ever made.
Sidelined by her group till she will be able to show that she doesn’t care about collateral harm (Shadows are given a strict routine of capsules to stifle their feelings), 13 is left to attend issues out in a squalid Jakarta high-rise… the place she instantly develops an emotional attachment to a teenage boy named Monji, who quickly finds himself kidnapped by the identical big-time native unhealthy guys who murdered his drug-addicted mom. Somewhat tenderness is usually a harmful factor to have in a world so powerful, and it isn’t lengthy earlier than 13 — scarred by a childhood lack of her personal — is bleeding a path straight to the guts of the Indonesian underworld, a lot to the chagrin of her employer. The phrases “paid time off” really imply nothing to some individuals.
That premise might sound to arrange a moderately simple film, however Tjahjanto’s indulgent streak forbids him from taking the shortest path to his story’s logical conclusion (an method befitting a film that has no logic or conclusion). Just like “The Night Comes for Us,” “The Shadow Strays” has much more plot than it wants and much too few causes for us to care about any of it — don’t sweat the main points, however it hinges on the overlap between an upcoming election and several other million {dollars} in stolen medicine. Preferring to emphasise coloration over readability, Tjahjanto litters this vacuous chunk of pulp fiction with larger-than-life characters who are supposed to create their very own inside mythology, together with Haga the pimp, his trigger-happy girlfriend Soriah, the crooked cop Prasetyo (“Posesif” star Adopati Dolken), a henchman with a coronary heart of gold, and a big grownup failson who likes to put on S&M gear whereas he tortures individuals for sport.
Not a single certainly one of these human sketches comes wherever near elaborating on their archetype, which doesn’t cease Tjahjanto from treating their meshwork of inside conflicts with the seriousness of a Russian novel; “The Shadow Strays” doesn’t endure from an absence of motion, however the lengthy and deeply uninvolving passages that encompass them create a continuing sense of restlessness all the identical. That Tjahjanto interrupts the movie’s lowest ebb with an prolonged detour about Umbra’s rising conscience suggests a profound overestimation of the viewer’s involvement on this story, as do quite a lot of different scenes that solely appear to exist in order that “The Shadow Strays” can lay the groundwork for a possible franchise that its worldbuilding is at the moment in no place to assist (the closing title card is instantly adopted by one of many busier post-credits scenes you’ll ever see). And but, for the entire stuff this film hopes to promote you on, it virtually utterly overlooks what little emotional depth it appears to dredge up alongside the best way. Intrigued by the patriarchal implications of a secret group that strips ladies of their instincts and company even because it turns them into unstoppable killing machines? Tjahjanto isn’t. Not less than not but. Possibly within the sequel.
And so we’re left to attend for the battle scenes, that are steadily “awesome” however seldom thrilling. Typical of the director’s work, the fight is just too quick to meaningfully interact with the surroundings round it (which explains why the final hour’s price of carnage is about in a sequence of empty areas), the digicam all the time feels prefer it’s just a few essential frames forward or behind of the place it needs to be for max affect, and the grappling model of Pencak silat has been suffused into the very cloth of compositions that tumble the other way up and again to their ft once more on a gimbal — which isn’t as satisfying to observe because it sounds on paper.
There’s no significant sense of escalation to the staging, and the performer’s talent and bodily sacrifice is usually diminished by geysers of digital blood, together with different CGI affectations that distract from the dynamism at hand. The beat the place a nasty man’s face is shoved into the fakest-looking burner fireplace you’ve ever seen is typical of a movie the place the trouble is never well worth the reward, whereas a top-down shot elsewhere in the identical sequence permits us to savor the uncooked technical aptitude that “The Shadow Strays” so typically loses in its eagerness to be as sick as potential.
In fact, that eagerness can be Tjahjanto’s biggest energy, and the place he succeeds is within the sheer brutality of his battle scenes. Much as my eyes glazed over throughout this movie’s prolonged setpieces, their interminability isn’t with out objective. Tjahjanto places his viewers by way of such a bruising onslaught of violence that we are able to’t assist however admire how crushed down and exhausted his characters should really feel, a trick of attrition that enables their rawest emotions to bleed proper by way of the display screen. The depth of 13’s feelings — her desperation to flee the ethical oblivion of her group — is so viscerally communicated by the fight scenes that it additional obviates the necessity for the entire leaden filler that surrounds them. All that muchness, and nothing to indicate for it. Tjahjanto desires so desperately to take advantage of badass motion film you’ve ever seen, and that’s a ravishing objective to have. I think the rewards would communicate for themselves if he merely set his sights on making a very good one first.
Grade: C
“The Shadow Strays” premiered on the 2024 Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition. Will probably be obtainable to stream on Netflix beginning Thursday, October 17.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the most effective opinions, streaming picks, and presents some new musings, all solely obtainable to subscribers.
