Anyone who got here of age throughout peak Orlando Bloom — when the British actor turned an impossibly fairly early 2000s intercourse image because the long-haired Legolas in “Lord of the Rings” or the swashbuckling Will Turner in “Pirates of the Caribbean” — will doubtless get a little bit of whiplash watching the actor’s left-turn pivot in “The Cut.” A sports activities drama with traces of physique horror in its veins, director Sean Ellis’ movie roughs up Bloom’s spotless face with some prosthetics (seamlessly performed by make-up designer Mark Coulier) to play an unnamed retired Irish boxer determined for a second likelihood at stardom.
Non-public faculty educated and longterm accomplice of Katy Perry, Bloom isn’t precisely a pure alternative for such a down-and-out sort, however the damaged nostril and droopy eyelids he places on do efficiently dispel most of his inherent film star glamor. And but, watching the movie, there’s one thing lacking from his efficiency — an interior depth, a starvation — to persuade as a lot as all of the make-up, and deepen the usually upsetting story of punishing your personal physique in pursuit of greatness into one thing extra compelling.
Starting with a fast glimpse on the final main bout of the boxer’s profession, earlier than an harm led to him being forged out of the glitzy world of Las Vegas prize fights, “The Cut” rapidly lays out the extra humble life he’s constructed for himself in the years since. On the one hand, there’s a loving relationship together with his accomplice and former coach Caitlin (Caitríona Balfe, convincing if woefully underserved in a typical “concerned spouse” function), working their very own gymnasium the place they provide classes to youngsters, and having sufficient native hero clout that there are nonetheless youthful college students begging their mothers to snap footage with him. Alternatively, there’s the mouthy and disrespectful youngsters he has to cope with, and a gnawing sense that he might have had and possibly deserved one thing higher.
So, when promoter Donny (Gary Beadle, overdoing the shadyness by a hair) exhibits up with a proposal to step in for a fighter who died unexpectedly earlier than a giant title struggle, the boxer is determined sufficient for an additional shot that he jumps on the supply regardless of all the warning indicators. Chief amongst them being: the load minimize off to be eligible is a flat 154 kilos. As Caitlin pries out of him when he tries to evade the query, he’s presently hovering round 186, and has a couple of week to shed the fats to qualify.
Though you would possibly initially count on “The Cut” to hurry by means of this complication with a coaching montage to get to the boxing, it quickly turns into clear that the battle to shed the kilos is the precise struggle the film is worried with. Of their nameless Vegas lodge, Caitlin and the boxer’s staff places the athlete to work, placing him on a food regimen of protein and salads whereas he undergoes fixed coaching in a foolhardy effort to get the load down fast and quick. It’s apparent from a really early level that there’s no approach that this might finish healthily, however the boxer is just too involved with the futile promise of the title to pay that a lot consideration, and Ellis dramatizes the psychological toll that the crash-diet and extreme routine has with persistence and a compelling trace of horror.
The warning indicators pop up early however sometimes: Visions of blood seeping out of meat, flashes of figures from the boxer’s previous showing in hallways as his mind suffers from the toil he’s placing on his physique. Notably upsetting and painful are the scenes the place Bloom binges and purges, swallowing a sweet bar earlier than barfing it again down the bathroom. Determined to shed the kilos, he alienates his staff and particularly Caitlin by taking over Boz (John Turturro, wickedly enjoyable in a job he might in all probability play in his sleep), a coach infamous for pushing his proteges to their restrict and interesting in dubiously moral strategies. Placing it bluntly throughout his preliminary assembly, Boz says he sees the boxer “as nothing but a poker chip,” which is a part of why he will get employed; Caitlin cares an excessive amount of to get the outcomes which can be wanted.
“The Cut” works greatest as a purely visceral expertise, as a dig into the bodily and psychological hell that Boz pushes Bloom’s character into. Ellis shoots the world of the movie with a darkish and dreary workmanlike sheen (Vegas has by no means been much less glamorous than it’s right here), however is keen to make nauseating pivots into dreamlike horror. The boxer begins seeing flashes of the much more well-known opponent he’s preventing out of the nook of his eye; individuals’s faces showing splattered in blood like demons in darkish inexperienced lighting, and all the world turns into hazy and out of focus. These moments of visible flourish are welcome, and one can think about a model of “The Cut” that leans in extra to the surreality to disquieting impact.
Sadly, although, “The Cut” doesn’t go all the best way with it, and too typically rests upon its naked bones storyline. The primary downside lies in the script, credited to Justin Bull and primarily based on a narrative by Mark Lane. It too typically renders the battle a little bit too neatly, with blunt dialogue and shallow characterization for its complete forged; notably irritating is the connection between Caitlin and the boxer, which needs to be the emotional middle of the movie however by no means actually lights into something lived-in or actual regardless of Balfe’s valiant efforts.
Black and white flashbacks to the boxer’s youth as a toddler throughout the Troubles goal to flesh out the lead’s obsessive quest for his ultimate shot however solely dillutes it as an alternative, decreasing his motivations to trite trauma and mom points. Because the boxer breaks down additional — taking capsules, getting blood transfusions to suck away the smallest ounces of weight away — the movie builds to a legitimately stomach-turning climax, solely to frustratingly finish on a be aware of ambiguity that feels neither like a hopeful reduction nor a fittingly tragic consequence.
Or possibly the ending would register extra with one other actor in the half. Bloom is useful sufficient because the boxer, however he doesn’t add extra to the movie than what’s on the web page. In comparison with Balfe or Turturro, who’re by no means lower than participating and plausible in their facet elements, the star by no means convincingly sinks into the function, or embodies the ache and anger driving the unnamed man to make him greater than only a cypher. His facial transformation apart, Bloom doesn’t ever appear to search out the physicality wanted for a movie so involved with flesh and bone. It’s straightforward to think about a performer extra attuned to ship intense, pushed performances unlock the total potential of this character. As it’s, “The Cut” by no means fairly cuts as deep as you need it to.
Grade: C+
“The Cut” premiered on the Toronto Worldwide Film Pageant. It’s presently in search of U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Overview by David Ehrlich, in which our Chief Film Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the most effective opinions, streaming picks, and affords some new musings, all solely obtainable to subscribers.
