There are many voices in R.J. Cutler’s “Martha,” the documentarian’s newest fascinating have a look at a cultural icon (on this case, the “original influencer” Martha Stewart), however there is just one speaking head who we truly see seated for an interview. Stewart, after all, who appears keen to inform her story — till she’s not — with Cutler well refusing to chop away when the wildly profitable entrepreneur and convicted felon (Stewart is nothing if not advanced) begins to balk, to noticeably grimace, at a line of questioning. Principally, it looks like issues are merely black and white to Stewart, besides — after all — a number of the finer particulars of her personal life.
As Cutler holds on Stewart, she has to interrupt the silence, giving only a smidge extra away with every passing phrase. Take into account a second within the movie‘s first act, as Stewart begins to unpack what led to the dissolution of her marriage to college sweetheart Andy Stewart: a defiant and clearly still very angry Martha initially offers some advice for the women out there, telling them if their husbands step out on them, leave them, full stop, and always regard them as the “piece of shit” they are. But, Cutler implores, didn’t Martha cheat on Andy earlier than he cheated on her? No!, Martha says. However Andy instructed the director that. Nicely, Martha shakes it off, that was totally different. Was it actually? To Stewart, it was.
It’s an instructive second, teasing the methods wherein Stewart sees the world and her place inside it: there are her guidelines, after which there are the foundations she will be able to break. If nothing else, viewers members will stroll away from “Martha” with a far higher understanding of Stewart — of all of the “good things,” in her parlance, and loads of the dangerous — and equal admiration and unease of what that each one provides as much as.
Stewart is clearly a genius, and “Martha” makes that plain, exhibiting off her enterprise acumen at each stage alongside the way in which. It wasn’t simply her concepts round what her model may very well be (heck, what a “brand” typically may very well be!) or her savvy tackle {the marketplace} (her option to take her wares to Ok-Mart was met with each derision after which massive, massive bucks) that made her stand out, that made her America’s first self-made feminine billionaire. She was additionally, as a few of these unseen speaking heads inform us, “a great white shark,” “a bitch,” and somebody who would have been seen way more favorably, had she been a person.
However she’s Martha. And on this world, her spin on being “perfectly perfect” was each rewarded and damned. Cutler’s problem? Promoting that complexity with a fair hand. Regardless of solely exhibiting Stewart within the scorching seat, Cutler and his group have assembled a large swath of different speaking heads (effectively, speaking voices) to spherical out her story. A lot of them, unsurprisingly sufficient, see a few of her best pleasure and deepest tragedies in several phrases that Stewart does. Early on, Stewart walks us via her childhood, punctuated by a tough-talking father who taught the children learn how to backyard (largely, they wanted to develop their very own meals, as a result of as formidable because the man was, he wasn’t excellent at his precise job), a reminiscence Stewart appears again on fondly and her siblings all keep in mind as being practically abusive. This dichotomy units the stage for what’s to return.
The movie is loosely divided into two elements, one taking us via Stewart’s adolescence, schooling, marriage, divorce, and large skilled success, the opposite following her via the 2004 trial that despatched her to jail for 5 months and all the pieces that occurred after that. The cut up is canny one — there was undoubtedly a “before” Martha and an “after” one — however each may simply be expanded, even doubled. Cutler’s movie begins to peter out in its remaining moments (the forging of Stewart’s extremely surprising bond with Snoop Dogg may foster its personal movie), however the journey there may be definitely fascinating. It’s a very good factor.
Grade: B
“Martha” premiered on the 2024 Telluride Movie Competition. Netflix will launch it at a later date.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Overview by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up the most effective critiques, streaming picks, and provides some new musings, all solely obtainable to subscribers.
