Erin Foster Is Working on ‘Nobody Wants This’ Season 2 — and She Has Ideas for Season 3

[This story contains spoilers from the season one finale of Nobody Wants This.]

“So, how does this work?” Erin Foster is already working on that reply.

The primary season of her Jewish rom-com No person Wants This adopted “hot rabbi” Noah (Adam Brody) and agnostic podcaster Joanne (Kristen Bell) falling in love — regardless of the obstacles, non secular and in any other case. For Joanne, that included getting over her “ick” issue and successful over Noah’s “perfect ex” fan membership. However Noah is in line to grow to be the pinnacle rabbi at his Los Angeles synagogue, which makes marrying somebody like Joanne, who isn’t Jewish, the largest complication. By the top of their 10-episode courtship, Joanne decides to transform to Judaism for Noah, solely to backtrack within the ultimate moments of the season. However simply whenever you assume they’re parting methods, Noah reveals up and chooses her.

What does this imply for his lifelong rabbinical aspirations? What’s going to his very opinionated Jewish household need to say? And, how will they navigate all of this as a pair?

Everyone seems to be now asking these questions, and everybody goes to get these solutions, finally. They’re simply going to have to attend till Rosh Hashanah subsequent 12 months.

No person Wants This has sparked for viewers across the globe, racking up thousands and thousands of viewership hours and spawning assume items and “hot rabbi” memes since its Sept. 26 debut. Foster, the podcaster daughter of music producer David Foster and Rebecca Dyer (who hosts The World’s First Podcast together with her sister and government producer Sara Foster, additionally her accomplice in style line Favourite Daughter), wrote No person Wants This primarily based on her personal life. Foster transformed to Judaism and married her husband Simon Tikhman; they now have a 5-month-old daughter.

Beneath, the creator spills on the modifications which might be in retailer for season two — making it clear what’s not in response to criticism — and says she is aware of what viewers need as she talks about her long-term plan: “Joanne does not have to have the same journey that I had. But, I don’t think this is the kind of show to rob the audience of what they want to see. I think this is a show where you want to get what you want.” She additionally displays on a present about Judaism being so standard amid a surge in antisemitism, shares how Netflix knew that they had successful earlier than the present even launched and reveals whether or not or not Brody has seen any of the memes.

***

What sort of a response have you ever gotten out of your Jewish group. Have you ever been bombarded at synagogue over the Jewish Excessive Holidays? [Editor’s note: We spoke ahead of Yom Kippur, on Oct. 11, one day after the season two renewal was announced.]

The response has been superior. I haven’t been to temple because the present got here out. [Her husband] Simon went to temple for Rosh Hashanah. He went to the daytime service alone. He and his dad and mom are going to companies [for Yom Kippur] and I’m staying dwelling with the newborn. So, hopefully they get bombarded.

I truly ought to throw myself into some actually Jewish environments whereas that is taking place, simply to get some consideration.

And a few materials for season two.

Actually.

It’s possible you’ll be accountable for serving to to transform folks to Judaism. To borrow a line out of your finale — within the dialog between Rebecca (Emily Arlook) and Joanne (Bell) — how are you dealing with this Jewish strain?

I get pleasure from it. It’s attention-grabbing. I used to be speaking to my mother about this. My mother went to the Nova exhibit [honoring victims of the Oct. 7 terror attack] on Thursday evening, and my mother now thinks she’s a star, as a result of she has folks coming as much as her speaking concerning the present. My mother actually looks like she has a Jewish soul, and she retains threatening to transform. So after the present she’s like, “I really think I should follow through with this.” And I’m like, “Ok mom, go ahead. Do it.”

On the flip facet, I’ve seen you discuss how personal your husband is and the anxiousness you had for your marriage when the present was popping out. Now that you just’ve been renewed, what’s his response to a different season?

I deliberately made season one so totally different from our actual life and our actual story, so we have been shielded from that. His dad and mom watched the present, and they didn’t see a lot of themselves within the characters. It’s important to take inventive license. Not solely as a result of it’s a TV present, however to drag away from the actual characters. Additionally, there’s not sufficient battle in my actual life. My in-laws, sadly, are very good to me, so there’s no enjoyable materials to mine from that. I feel I’ve been threading the needle completely, up to now.

Might you assign a proportion of how a lot was pulled out of your life?

That’s a superb query. The emotional themes of the present are actually, actually correct to my actual expertise. It’s simply that the conditions aren’t the identical. I did really feel a way of being an outsider coming into my relationship with my husband in a method that I didn’t anticipate. I grew up with so many Jewish associates, and I by no means felt like there was a separation or a distinction. There was no highlighted place that I used to be in as a non-Jewish individual. I might go to my good friend’s Rosh Hashanah dinners with their households, and in order that [feeling] actually wasn’t a think about my life.

So after I began relationship Simon, and I realized the distinction with immigrant dad and mom and how they really feel about Judaism, I used to be form of confused. I used to be like, “Why am I feeling like I’m this wrong-side-of-the-tracks person in your life, because I’ve never felt like that before?” I feel I didn’t have an appreciation for the expertise of immigrants coming right here and the burden that being Jewish carries for them, and the significance of constant a Jewish lineage. I used to be simply studying as I went alongside, and it was fascinating. I can look again on it in hindsight with the flexibility to create one thing from it. However within the second, it was very intimidating.

I learn that the “ick” scene was ripped out of your actual life, and that Simon equally introduced a big bouquet of sunflowers when first assembly your dad and mom. With regards to your courtship with Simon and how Noah and Joanne’s romance performs out, what was off limits?

The second in “The Ick” [episode] when Noah pulls Joanne apart and says, “You gotta stop this. We like each other. Get your shit together,” that was an actual second that occurred with me and Simon. And it wasn’t from the flowers, essentially, it was simply various things that have been taking place that made me really feel like, “This guy is too emotionally available. He’s too into me and he’s not playing any games, and this just feels like it’s not for me. I don’t think this person can handle me, because he’s too pure. That can’t possibly be a guy that’s going to keep up with me.”

And after I pulled away, as a result of I used to be spooked by that, as an alternative of him grabbing on tighter and panicking — like we do as human beings once we really feel somebody pulling away, we spiral and grow to be even much less interesting — as an alternative of doing that, he actually stood in himself. He stood sturdy and was very unwavering. He was like, “I see what you’re doing. I need you to take a beat. I’m not going anywhere. And when you’re ready to stop this spinning out that you’re doing, I’ll be right here; you know where to find me.” It simply woke me up. I used to be 35 years outdated and hadn’t had anybody have that dialog with me.

While you’re creating one thing, you don’t know what the response goes to be within the second. While you’re combating for one thing to be there [in the show], you don’t know in case you are on an island. Like, perhaps that second was solely significant to me as a result of it occurred to me? And so after I was combating to get that second in [the show] and combating for issues to not get minimize — I used to be like, “This feels important. I need her to turn around and not be able to look at him when she’s feeling vulnerable. These are things that I feel connected to and I need to see them.” You don’t know if that’s going to return out and nobody will get it. So when it got here out and all people will get it — they’re like, “Ugh, this is me. That’s an experience I’ve had” or, “That’s an experience I would want to have” — that’s essentially the most validating factor.

I feel my expertise is a common expertise. That’s the factor you need to stroll into as a author. You need the viewers to be experiencing it as in the event that they have been experiencing it themselves, that’s the objective.

So, No person Wants This launched and shortly ascended to the very high of Netflix and hung on the market for some time.

Till Love Is Blind got here again. Actually, I participated in that, as a result of I’m watching Love is Blind.

It had a future as No. 1. On this present local weather of surging antisemitism, your Jewish rom-com is the preferred present. What do you make of that? I do know whenever you went via the method of changing to Judaism, you have been requested in case you have been actually able to be Jewish and expertise every part that comes with that, together with antisemitism.

It’s an attention-grabbing social experiment. I’ve stated this earlier than, however after I was doing the ultimate steps of changing and was requested if I used to be able to be hated, able to have antisemitism put in my face, I didn’t know what I used to be signing up for. As a result of on the time, it was 2019 and these conversations weren’t as outstanding as they’re immediately, or as they even have been in 2020. I stated sure to one thing that I didn’t even actually perceive. It took me being Jewish whereas antisemitism was having such a surge, and is having such a surge, to actually perceive what that meant. And nothing has made me really feel extra Jewish than experiencing it like this immediately.

There are tens of thousands and thousands of individuals watching the present, and loving the present. And loving Adam Brody as a rabbi and loving the little tidbits of Judaism that you just find out about. These, statistically, need to be a number of the people who find themselves supporting sure agendas which might be anti-Jewish. And I don’t even assume they know that’s what they’re doing, clearly, if they’re loving the present. So I feel there’s a number of hypocrisy going on. If there may be any individuals who watch and this present makes them perhaps second guess one thing that they reposted that they didn’t perceive, and for them to clock the quantity of individuals they could have damage, or that perhaps they only don’t know sufficient concerning the factor that they’re speaking about, I hope that may occur. As a result of these people who find themselves loving the present have to like some side of Judaism. So, the numbers aren’t making sense.

I learn that many locations turned you down whenever you pitched this present, earlier than you bought to Netflix.

Hulu, Apple, FX. Others might have handed on even listening to the pitch, too.

By the point the season two renewal got here down, No person Wants This had racked up nearly 90 million hours of viewing worldwide. When did your conversations begin with Netflix a couple of second season?

They have been getting early information earlier than the present got here out. They’ve a lot of alternative ways the place they check how a present goes to do. They do inside screenings, they’ve screeners that get despatched out to sure subscribers. And so they had a extremely excessive variety of folks finishing the sequence. Even internally within the Netflix group, globally, there are workers who get early entry. And so they have been like, “We’re seeing this completion rate that’s really high.” It’s form of a microcosm of what occurs exterior these workplaces. So I used to be feeling fairly good going into it. However, how might I ever have imagined it might be like this? I simply couldn’t.

As quickly because it got here out, and it was shortly doing effectively, I couldn’t think about a world the place they weren’t going to offer us a season two. However even so far as [the week of Oct. 7, before the renewal announcement], the Netflix executives got here into the writers room and I used to be like, “When are we announcing season two?” And so they have been like, “We can’t really tell you.” And I used to be like, “Well, we’re in the writers room…”

So, you have got already had the writers room up for season two?

Yeah, we’ve had the room up for about three weeks. They greenlit a second season writers room earlier than a second season manufacturing. These are two various things. That is a part of what the writers strike was about [protections for pre-greenlight rooms during the development process], the place typically rooms would get a greenlight with out seasons. However this type of made it extra enjoyable. It stretches out the method of getting the inexperienced gentle.

Effectively whenever you wrote the primary season, you clearly didn’t know any of this but. And also you ended season one on a serious cliffhanger. Had been you ready to just accept this “So, how does this work?” ending between Noah and Joanne if the present had ended on this method?

By no means figuring out? I form of all the time operated with the hope of a season two. While you’re on set and you’re in modifying and experiencing it, the chemistry between Adam and Kirsten was palpable. You’d watch on display screen and we felt like, “Oh, we think we struck something that’s really special here.” So I assume I form of all the time regarded on the present in modifying with the concept of, “Where would we take it next, if we could?”

Have you considered a long-term sport plan? Are you pondering three seasons, 5… seven? Is there a quantity?

I’d prefer to be employed so long as attainable, I assume. There are a number of tales to inform. It’s humorous as a result of, we’ve been within the writers room and so we’re working on storylines, and we preserve developing with storylines and being like, “That’s for season three. That’s for season three.” And we’re like, “Should we just make a board and pitch out season three to them at the same time?” As a result of, we now have concepts.

One thing that ended up being particular concerning the present, that I actually have to offer Netflix credit score for pushing us to do, was to let the story unfold actually slowly in season one. Initially, after I developed the concept, I had seen [Noah and Joanne] getting engaged or married by the finale of season one, and once we obtained into the writing course of Netflix saved being like, “Slow it down, slow it down. We don’t want to get there too quickly.” And it ended up being actually nice storytelling, as a result of it makes you’re feeling such as you’re experiencing the connection in actual time. You possibly can watch a present and have these manufactured time jumps, the place you don’t actually expertise the minutia of how a relationship unfolds, and so we have been actually. in a position to try this.

So in pondering of season two, I don’t need to break that system that we now have in place. I feel we’ll choose up principally kind of the place we left off. Not the identical evening, however the identical second of, “So, what now? How do we do this?”

In your actual life, you transformed to Judiasm. Are we purported to take that as a spoiler, or might Joanne’s path be totally different?

Joanne doesn’t need to have the identical journey that I had in actual life. We all the time use my experiences as a template to leap off of, if it really works and if the room actually responds to it. However she’s her personal individual. She has her personal story, for certain. So, I don’t know. It might go both method. But in addition, I don’t assume that is the form of present to make creative decisions that rob the viewers of what they need to see. I feel this can be a present the place you need to get what you need; you don’t need to be fucked with. I’m not making an attempt to dangle issues and not give them to folks.

You’ve weighed in on a number of the criticism across the present. (There have been essays on the “shiksa goddess” trope, and criticism about Jewish stereotypes and how the Jewish ladies have been portrayed.) You’ve stated these aren’t Jewish stereotypes, they’re comedy stereotypes. Are you able to discuss concerning the Jewish make up of your writers room and, what have been a number of the large discussions round season one and/or classes realized that you just’re bringing into season two?

There have been a number of Jewish writers season one. We had an actual mish-mosh of people that had transformed to Judaism as adults, individuals who grew up Jewish, individuals who have been Jewish however had spouses who weren’t Jewish, individuals who grew up in additional conservative households or much less conservative households. And actually, the irony is that it was usually Jewish writers who have been saying, “Let me make sure the parents feel like real Jewish parents.” I feel it’s form of you’re damned in case you do, you’re damned in case you don’t. As a result of in case you go in opposition to stereotype then you definately’ll be accused of not figuring out the way to write Jewish characters. And in case you go in the direction of stereotypes, I assume individuals are going to be upset about that as effectively.

However I feel in case you take a look at the present as an entire, a number of the criticism needs to disregard that we now have a feminine rabbi [played by Leslie Grossman] who is actually accepting of Joanne. We even have a number of actually flawed characters who are usually not Jewish; Joanne is a extremely flawed character. There’s this hyper focus on the feminine Jewish characters being stereotypes, however there’s an actual lack of acknowledgment about how sturdy they’re as ladies, and how they’re the matriarchs of the household. They’re not these passive housewives who don’t have opinions and or a say of their household. They’re the authoritarian of their relationship in a method that’s cool.

Esther [played by Jackie Tohn] is a extremely loyal good friend to Rebecca, that’s why she doesn’t like Joanne. Not as a result of Joanne isn’t Jewish. She doesn’t give a shit. She’s loyal to her good friend Rebecca. So, we’re going to proceed telling the story in season two and fleshing these characters out as we all the time deliberate to do, and not as a response to criticism. As a result of I feel nearly all of folks see that this can be a net-positive for Jewish folks usually.

We noticed each Esther and Rebecca evolve by the finale, so I used to be going to ask how you intend to flesh them out extra in season two. Will they play as large of roles?

Yeah. We’re nonetheless taking part in round with the totally different tales. Esther for certain, goes to be an everyday in season two. We love Jackie, she is such a enjoyable actress. And she or he actually gave Esther some enjoyable, nuanced stuff. Like in episode two when she pulls as much as the bar and she’s saying, “Whore No. 1” and “Whore No. 2” and she’s screaming, “Get the fuck in the car.” After which she’s like [to her husband Sasha, played by Timothy Simons], “Hi honey! OK, 4-3-2-1.” That’s a selection Jackie made that was actually enjoyable. Like, I act mad at my husband, however then we even have a cute, candy relationship. So I’m excited to see what she does with every part we give her in season two.

And the Rebecca character was all the time one thing I used to be actually enthusiastic about. Whereas perhaps somebody criticizing her might see a lady who’s obsessive about getting married, and that being a Jewish stereotype, that wasn’t the intention. The intention behind her was truly a candy, stunning, fantastic, educated, perfect-on-paper Jewish lady that your dad and mom would love for you to be with. And, that you ought to be with, in a number of methods, as a result of your life is sensible collectively. And you understand precisely what your life would appear to be in case you have been with that lady, and it might be a fantastic life. However one thing doesn’t really feel proper, and you don’t know what it’s. I really like the concept of an ideal ex-girlfriend haunting your present relationship. Each lady can relate to having an obsession with the ex, and particularly if she’s excellent on paper. And that’s actually the place the inspiration got here from with Rebecca.

You do be taught a lot extra about her within the finale. You perceive her wrestle extra and empathize with who she is. So we’re going to proceed doing that. We’re not going to jot down for a response to criticism.

You introduced in new showrunners for season two —  Jenni Konner and Bruce Eric Kaplan, in addition to EP Nora Silver. [Foster was co-showrunner on season one with Jack Burdit.] What they are going to convey to the present and why the change?

I simply really feel so fortunate to have Jenni, Bruce and Nora, as a result of I’m an enormous Ladies fan. I beloved Ladies. I noticed Tiny Furnishings earlier than Lena [Dunham] then went on to make Ladies. I’m an enormous fan of their style stage. With season one, we had a wild rush of scripts. We had the writers strike in the midst of our writers room. It turned tremendous chaotic. We misplaced writers within the course of. It wasn’t unprecedented, as a result of it’s occurred earlier than, but it surely was a difficult factor to throw into the center of every part. For season two, we simply wanted a brand new course of, and we wanted to determine what that regarded like. I actually wanted to focus on being the voice of the present, and the writing. Being showrunner is just like the job of 10 folks, so I used to be so excited to have them are available in and assist ensure that the inventive stays hyper-focused, and that I may be in my lane. They’ve been nice. I simply obtained actually fortunate. It’s been nice within the room, to only have folks there whose style I really like and to have a extremely good course of. And I get to listen to all of the behind-the-scenes Ladies tales.

You beforehand stated you auditioned “every hot Jewish actor in town” for Noah. Who was runner-up or who got here near Adam Brody?

Mmm, nice query. There wasn’t a detailed second. I need to give a extra enjoyable reply, however nobody had the heat that Adam had, and the attraction and confidence. That candy boy subsequent door, however somebody who can even let you know to place your ice cream down [in the first kiss scene]. It was simply him.

One other large piece of criticism from viewers is that they need extra, or longer, episodes subsequent season. Is that something you might be pushing for?

(Laughs) I might love that. That’s so humorous. I’m fairly certain we’re solely getting 10 episodes, which looks as if a full season to me. I feel it’s all the time higher leaving folks asking for extra, as an alternative of individuals wishing that there have been much less. If it ain’t broke, don’t repair it. However longer episodes [thinking], I don’t find out about. As a result of, they have been actually quick. I’m curious if that’s one thing Netflix would need us to proceed or change.

You would push the episodes to 40 minutes, or 30-something.

That may be good. Look, I’m all the time a fan of longer. I all the time get accused of needing to trim my scenes down. I all the time over write.

Adam Brody spoke to us about how a lot prep work he did to play a rabbi, and how severely he took this function. And Kristen had her hand on this present from the beginning; as I perceive you initially envisioned this function for your self however then gave her your blessing when Netflix introduced this to her. What have their reactions been across the response to the present?

Adam is a really offline individual, which is actually so annoying. As a result of I’m like, “I need you to be seeing these memes about you.” We actually created a pretend Twitter account for him simply so he might go on Twitter and see, and he’s like, “No, I can’t.” He’s too mentally wholesome to permit himself to enter these darkish holes. And, I respect it. And Kristen got here into the room this week with Justine to listen to some storylines that we have been working on. She says she hasn’t gotten a response to something like this, actually, since Frozen. It’s loopy. They’re simply so glad, after all. They’re excellent in these roles.

And also you didn’t even chemistry check them.

No! It was an enormous threat. I used to be like, “What if these guys don’t vibe on camera?” After which we watched on digital camera and we have been like, “Are they having an affair? This is steamy!”

Are you able to share what you have got in retailer for their onscreen siblings, Sasha [Simmons] and Morgan [Lupe], in season two?

I feel we’re going to wrap up their bizarre “Is it romantic?” factor. As a result of we need to see them collectively in season two, hanging out. We need to see Esther. I feel we went down that street sufficient that now we’re going to drag again and reposition so we are able to have all of them in scenes collectively with out [Morgan] being like, a full homewrecker. However we’re going to offer Morgan one thing very enjoyable. Justine got here in and we pitched it to her and she was like, “This is my dream storyline.” It’s so enjoyable.

Since you might be working on season two, might it come out earlier than a 12 months from now?

No. It takes a lot longer than you’ll ever assume. It’s mainly going to be coming again, in all probability, in September once more subsequent 12 months. Yearly, the identical time, we’ll be actually constant. We’re simply going to be a Rosh Hashanah launch, all the time (laughs).

And, I used to be questioning, did considered one of your writers actually have a “So-and-So Takes a Bite Out of the Big Apple” as their bar or bat mitzvah theme?

Oh my God, sure. There was a author who labored on the present early on and her husband had that as his bar mitzvah theme. I feel his grandmother compelled it on him and we have been like — that’s so humorous, we now have to make use of that. It’s humorous, the issues that survive all through the present, and that this nonetheless ended up being the precise factor we did. As a result of normally, whenever you pitch one thing early on, somebody beats it. It turns into one thing else or one thing higher. However that one was simply one of the best.

***

No person Wants That is now streaming all episodes on Netflix.