“We’re in the same business,” pleads the world’s unluckiest Santa impersonator to an armed-and-ready Art the Clown. “We make people happy.”
Evaluating job descriptions gained’t save Santa or his cherry-red nostril and beard of white from what awaits in “Terrifier 3” — however he makes a good level. Returning for a second sequel in this indie-slasher-turned-runaway-train, star David Howard Thornton reprises his position as Art: a supernatural shepherd of theatrical pleasure.
Splatter isn’t for everybody and, even Christmas themed, “Terrifier 3” is intense. But when gore, guts, and go-for-broke horror-comedy are in your pre-Halloween want record, then Damien Leone’s finest movie will slap a smile in your face so huge it’d as properly be held there with meat hooks.
We meet up with Art 5 years after the occasions of “Terrifier 2.” Snowy and scary in that cozy “Black Christmas” manner, the chilly open takes us inside a glowing suburban dwelling the place an unsuspecting household is quick asleep. When a Cindy Lou Who kind toddles downstairs to discover a black-and-white Grinch poking round the tree, she tries to warn her mother, dad, and brother about the intrusion to no avail. The household could not stay to see morning, however collectively the 4 holly-jolly meat sacks will signpost the guidelines of this grim and gleeful subsequent chapter.
Sure, Art is killing youngsters. And sure, he’s nonetheless torturing girls. That’s positive to outrage of us who hated “Terrifier 2” — though they haven’t any enterprise seeing “Terrifier 3.” And even those that preferred the previous movies’ extra could discover themselves wishing the really agonizing first scene was sooner. Nonetheless, Leone’s misunderstood endurance check is aware of itself properly sufficient to not make excessive carnage its solely promoting level.
Pulsing with model, Art’s newest outing is a fascinating testomony to the “Terrifier” group’s knack for fantasy world-building. It’s additionally proof that ultra-violence can promote paranormal ideas that may in any other case appear too goofy for the huge display screen. When the final individual alive in Art’s preliminary rampage screams their manner into the title card, “Terrifier 3” embraces the soul of the sequence as if for the first time — presenting a vignette so upsetting it’s borderline biblical.
Audiences who haven’t seen a “Saw” movie are sometimes shocked to study these so-called “torture porn” films are principally dense police procedurals. In that very same vein, “Terrifier” movies are mythic explorations of splatter-punk model and the slasher as an idea. These horror fantasies use over-the-top results to touch upon style and experiment with tropes, whether or not you realize it or not. And whereas that’s not at all times been executed properly, working with an even bigger funds and crew for “Terrifier 3,” Leone makes the strongest case for his creation but.
The Santa-of-it-all (which truthful warning, dovetails into the Jesus-of-it-all) helps prop up The Killer Clown Who Can’t Be Killed as a legendary horror icon worthy of the field workplace success he’s loved to this point. Revealing itself like a forbidden graphic novel, this really epic descent into vacation hell begins with a prelude that makes use of brutal results and fairytale imagery to create its personal sort of demented nativity. Soaked in blood and seated at that poor household’s kitchen counter, Art ends his repulsive warm-up act consuming milk and cookies, washing the dishes, and grinning ear to ear as “Come All Ye’ Faithful” blares in the background.
It’s a panoramic scene (not solely in the sense that it makes you wish to choke) and an apparent accomplishment to individuals who know the subgenre properly. Should you get catharsis from shock worth horror matched with sharp comedy, then this visually and tonally placing movie is for you. And if you happen to’re a nerd who loves a hidden gem superhero saga — who’s keen to danger the risk of incurring extreme, irreversible psychological injury at the films — then this movie can also be for you.
Dazzling and formidable as ever with a backstory rooted in her lifeless dad’s comedian books, Sienna Shaw (Lauren LaVera) is again to battle Art a second time. The ultimate woman’s nightmarish run-in with the Miles County Clown from the final film has her dwelling in a psychiatric care middle at the begin of “Terrifier 3.” The Christmas season affords an incredible excuse for Sienna to go to her now college-aged brother Jonathan (Elliot Fullam) and their prolonged household, who’re understandably cautious of the siblings’ previous.
It’s simpler to embrace lore about an ark angel and a magical sword with glowing vacation ornaments in the body — and Leone places his entire chest into establishing that exposition for fulfillment. A assured and comfy script explores the recognizable sequel archetype of a traumatized hero like a recent iceberg, presenting Sienna as steely and stoic on the exterior, whereas permitting her hallucinations and journal entries to languish in the sordid previous she’ll must recap.
By that, Leone higher develops the already-dead characters he might have stated extra about in “Terrifier 2” and evokes the sort of sudden cameos seen in “Scream,” “Halloween,” and different history-making slashers. The filmmaker understands the spirit of horror and the “Terrifier” world feels ever-more vibrant and alive due to that appreciation. He additionally is aware of write a feminist fantasy hero. Certain, Sienna wears sort of a bodacious battle outfit in “Terrifier 2,” however even dressed in a Christmas sweater, she is as reluctantly empowered as any Valkyrie.
“I got into a fight,” Sienna says casually, when requested about the scars she bought whereas being on full-on flayed by Art in the final movie. “Yeah, I won.” (See? Superhero shit! And he or she’s by no means as soon as been pressured to entertain a boyfriend.)
They are saying behind each immortal demon clown there’s a powerful, traumatized girl. Art has two. Earlier than he crosses paths with Sienna once more, we’ll observe his slapstick antics to a reunion with survivor-turned-accomplice Vicky (Samantha Scaffidi), who’s Leone’s secret weapon as unearthed in a key flashback. The unique “Terrifier” sufferer, Vicky was in a psychological hospital at one time too. Now, she’s the Sally to Art’s Jack Skellington — and dealing on one thing way more sinister than an imposter Santa go well with.
Capable of spook even Art on a whim, Vicky aimlessly shuffles round, cutely honks a motorcycle horn, and generally…masturbates with glass? Yeesh. As her supernatural character builds and the risky half she performs in Art’s propulsive reign of terror turns into extra clear, dreamlike visions start to terrorize Sienna. All through the festivities along with her aunt Jessica (Margaret Anne Florence), uncle Greg (Bryce Johnson), and cousin Gabbie (Antonella Rose), our heroine is plagued with crippling guilt and overwhelmed by an imminent sense that the clown isn’t completed along with her but.
“Terrifier” has been referred to as sexist schlock that offers horror a nasty title, and making the controversial choice to go after underage victims gained’t assist its popularity. That stated, the suggestion that Leone’s work in some way betrays feminine horror followers says extra about the acceptability of utmost nudity and violence in movie proper now than something about this explicit author or director. Along with championing Sienna each step of the manner, “Terrifier 3” takes a number of sensible corrective measures in that dialog — at one level offering (non-sexual) proof that Art has a penis as weak as anybody else’s.
Sienna and Vicky get loads of story to hold and the woman-centric ensemble effort ensures Thornton’s “Who, me?!” clown act — this time, that includes liquid nitrogen and killing sprees at the native mall — by no means will get outdated. Art and Vicky (“Art + Vicky,” if you’ll) are connected at the hip for many of their display screen time, however leaping between the three outrageous characters makes for an unpredictable rhythm that appears like getting squeezed by a tunnel.
Sienna’s paranoia matches with the couple’s nauseating chemistry and virtually each boring second from the previous two movies fades into reminiscence. The colourful and demonic coronary heart of “Terrifier 3” beams brightest when the severity of what’s coming for Sienna is intercut straight into her paralyzing worry of it. Eyes brimming with tears, actress LaVera sells these beats as a bonafide scream queen who simply as properly might have been solid as an Avenger. (That’s not a suggestion that Ms. LaVera pursue work with Marvel; she is so a lot better than that I’d sooner salt my very own again. But when anybody might theoretically make me care about these films once more, it’s most likely her.)
Scenes from Jonathan’s faculty provide a humorous and welcome reprieve from that nerve-shredding trinity of terror — till they actually don’t, and “Terrifier 3” provides its most bafflingly terrible characters what’s coming to them. An overzealous, sexed-up true crime podcaster named Mia (Alexa Blair Robertson) and her fool boyfriend Cole (Mason Mecartea), who can also be Jonathan’s roommate, could also be this film’s Achilles heel. And that’s not simply because considered one of them experiences the most graphic slip-and-fall in horror historical past.
Mia and Cole seem in a jaw-dropping assault sequence that’s intelligent as a result of it performs as a cheeky reversal of a franchise kill we’ve already seen, but it surely’s additionally complicated when thought of as Leone’s newest assertion on problematic fandoms. The filmmaker could be smart to make satirizing the thorny panorama surrounding his work the next precedence in the already-confirmed “Terrifier 4.” However he chews by as a lot meta-fruit cake as he can right here and that backlash would require extra untangling than even the worst string lights.
For now, “Terrifier 3” is decking the halls with a triumphant celebration that’s horrifying for all the proper causes and snaps into focus what it’s that Leone does singularly properly. Which will or could not win individuals over, but it surely shouldn’t lose any repeat prospects. Superbly rendered, oozing with perception in itself, and boasting an unbelievable ultimate act, Art the Clown’s vacation extravaganza (which, sure, comes full with an unique Christmas carol) is likely to be extra naughty — however “Terrifier” by no means tried more durable to play good.
Grade: B+
“Terrifier 3” premiered at Unbelievable Fest 2024 on September 19. It’s in theaters nationwide on October 11 and anticipated to debut on Screambox in 2025.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, in which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the finest evaluations, streaming picks, and affords some new musings, all solely out there to subscribers.
